Language is power and
a tool used to empower students. In the article by Canagarajah it explains how
diverse language is. Besides that, Canagarajah also explains that as future
educators especially we should instead of trying to push “Metropolitan English”
which is language spoken by dominant society such as the United States, Canada,
etc. But instead we should encourage students to use their primary language to
assist them in mastering grammar. Besides that, Canagarajah goes into details
explaining how we only use other World English’s when it is not in a formal
situation. This shows how lesser we think of those who do not speak what we
view as standard English. The reason is because we automatically have this
negative connotation that those who cannot write properly or speak flawlessly
then they are then seen as not a smart. But then how can we judge someone for
that when they are not smart based on our standard not theirs or their
community. This is something that Canagarajah focuses on which is trying to
break this barrier what we view as standard English and trying to show that
there is no right way to speak English.
Besides just another
languages Canagarajah also explains that teachers should also accept other
English language that students speak just like African American English or
different versions of English that students from different parts of the world
speak. I think though we should still try to teach students basic grammar
rules, we should not try to limit their language and speech by telling them the
English they speak is wrong.
I think one of the biggest things I’ve
learned is seeing how as a teacher it is more than merely teaching your subject
to your students, but it is also trying to incorporate others language and
cultures as a way to explain lesson. I think this ultimately is the most
important thing as a teacher we can do. The reason being is because it will
show students that one culture is not more important than theirs. But instead
were all equal. By showing students that it will get students to want to
experiment more with language and take chances because they won’t be
embarrassed. Besides that, I’ve also learned that different languages aren’t just
about people from different countries speaking different language, but also
understanding that the way someone speaks English the way you do that instead of
telling them their grammar is lesser we should encourage students to use that
language.
Language—though unique—should be taught
to students in Middle and High School. The reason is because during this time
many students are trying to discover themselves and coming to terms with themselves.
Language is a huge part of that. By being able to teach students about incorporating
their own language in whether their writing or learning grammar. By teaching
that is shows students that it isn’t merely just using full and complete
sentences, but understanding that when I drop the -g in many words isn’t because
I don’t understand how to write. But because that’s the type of speech I am
familiar with.
Tihesha,
ReplyDeleteYou did a great job of summarizing the article by Canagarajah. You chose great focus points such as how the author believes that there is no right way to speak English. I agree with the point you made about how it is important that we continue to teach students grammar. Although students shouldn't have to study only standard English, it will still be important in their future's that they understand it well.
You used the dash well in your first sentence of your last paragraph. I could clearly see the emphasis put on the words "though unique" bu the dashes before and after. If you wanted to make it more of a subtle statement then you could also try using commas. For example "Language, though unique, should be taught to students in Middle and High School". You could also try to incorporate a complex sentence in your third paragraph by saying "I think this is the most important thing we can do as a teacher, because it will show students that one culture is not more important than theirs."
I really enjoyed reading your post!
Tihesha,
ReplyDeleteAs I see, the main idea of your post is the equality for every variety of English. You summarized the article really well, and, what I value the most, showed it to your reader through your own prism of thought. However, while reading your post, I didn't encounter too many sentences with the patterns of this week. You use dash and compound sentences, but not many complex sentences. Therefore, I am going to suggest to change couple of your sentences into the patterns of the week. You have a great sentence about students being able to experiment with the language. I can suggest to change it to the following one: Students, while they experiment with the language, shouldn't be embarrassed. The next sentence can come from a three different sentences, located next to each other, and it sounds like this:A teacher, while instructs on the subject of the language, shows the students that their own culture in not less important then any other culture. You have great thoughts in your post, and I enjoyed reading it!
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete